Thirty years of aerospace CNC programming and setup experience.

Currently running production because the shop is short staffed. Machine’s running. Floor’s swept. Bench is clean. Next job is staged.

Six-minute cycle.

Pick up your phone? Management has a problem.

Sit on a stool and stare at the wall? Apparently that’s professional manufacturing.

A machinist brought this situation to the MACHINIST group and asked:

❝

“Do I work in Romper Room?”

With 1,300 reactions and 955 comments on the post, he found plenty of people familiar with the curriculum.

His actual request was pretty simple:

❝

“I would love to be treated like an adult for once... give me a job, leave me alone, and let me get it done.”

Naturally, the comments became a calm, orderly discussion about workplace expectations.

Just kidding. We got management complaints, phone arguments, toolbox wheels, and a proposed modification to Machinery’s Handbook.

Let’s get into it.

Making parts or looking busy?

This was the biggest frustration in the thread: getting everything running smoothly, then getting grief because it doesn’t look like you’re doing enough.

Steven Hall recalled working beneath an owner’s office that overlooked the CNC machines. The owner called down to ask why he wasn’t working.

His manager’s response:

❝

“He’s done his job well all the machines are running that’s what you pay him to do!”

The owner suggested sweeping. According to Steven, his manager eventually offered another solution: next time the owner looks out, stop a machine and pretend to do something.

Beautiful. We’ve successfully replaced production with a live demonstration of effort.

Another commenter, posting as GlowingPapaya5619, said they were reprimanded for sitting after getting four machines running and cleaning their area. Later, they became a full-time programmer at the same company.

❝

“Sit down all day long lol. I don’t get it.”

Same ass. Different job title. Suddenly approved for seating.

Yes, some people absolutely ruin it

The other side had plenty to say, too. And some of it was fair.

There’s a difference between checking your phone during a proven cycle and letting a machine sit idle because you’re committed to finding out how a stranger’s driveway gets pressure-washed.

Nic Hawkey described the problem: some people put the phone down immediately when the cycle ends. Others finish their video first.

David Michael McClure shared a worse example: an employee watching the World Series went two days without checking parts. The scrap was discovered when someone else took over and inspected the first piece.

That’ll put a dent in the “my work gets done” argument.

Former owner Steve Fulwiler acknowledged both sides: phones can help with the job, and they can pull attention away from it. The difficulty comes when people abuse the freedom.

Jason McLemore translated that into shop language:

❝

“Somebody shit their pants and now we all have to wear diapers!”

There it is. The employee handbook, condensed to one sentence.

But that’s also what frustrated so many experienced people in the thread. Someone else can’t manage their time, and suddenly the person who programs, sets up, checks parts, and keeps production moving needs kindergarten rules.

The phone is forbidden. Please answer my text.

Several commenters pointed out that their phones are also work tools.

Calculators. Machining references. Messages to maintenance, quality, and programmers.

Bryan Blackburn said his shop banned phones, so employees started walking around to find the people they previously could text.

Then came the punchline:

❝

“Supervisors still try to text us on them. 🙄”

Chad Marchand described employers who want phones kept in employees’ pockets so they can be contacted—while also telling them not to use them.

Please carry this prohibited device at all times. We may need you.

A few commenters also raised customer confidentiality and camera restrictions. Those can be a separate discussion. Todd’s complaint was about being allowed to stare at a wall while catching grief for looking at a screen.

The wall presumably has an excellent scrap record.

The comments department offered solutions

Some practical. Some requiring a meeting with HR.

Ken Clay suggested:

❝

“Find an old Machinery’s handbook and cut out a space big enough for your phone.”

This immediately prompted concern for the handbook, because even during a management argument, machinists have standards.

Neil Harrison improved the proposal:

❝

“use the employee handbook instead, look like a real keener!”

ReliableArugula2783 offered a less destructive approach:

❝

“just keep measuring the entire part over and over again until they leave”

Somewhere, a perfectly acceptable diameter is getting checked for the 47th time.

And when Mark Sersland reminded everyone:

❝

“You are at work not At home”

PleasantMoose9136 replied:

❝

“thats why I’m not drinking”

Thank you for clarifying the workplace boundaries.

Some managers have figured this out

Thankfully, the thread also had examples of shops where adults get treated like adults.

Shop manager Mark Jacobs said he allows phones and earbuds as long as they don’t interfere with production. In his experience, that approach has helped productivity and kept employees happy.

He acknowledged that someone occasionally pushes the limits. He still considers the effort worthwhile.

Former engineering operations manager Duncan Harris described a team run with weekly goals, morning and afternoon check-ins, and trust. His advice included knowing the trade well enough to spot bullshit and understanding the people doing the work.

That sounds more useful than checking whether someone has been visibly uncomfortable for their entire shift.

Justin Councell explained why he stays at his current shop even though he believes he could earn considerably more elsewhere: freedom, control over his work, and an employer who leaves him to get on with it.

Being left alone to do a job you’re good at has real value.

About that staffing shortage…

Todd opened by saying he’s running production because they’re short staffed.

The comments did not let that detail slide.

Paul Knight put it this way:

❝

“Treat me wrong, poof! Magically more understaffed.”

Larry Hartman, who said he’s been at this since 1976, offered the familiar reminder:

❝

“My tool box has wheels for a reason.”

Nobody needs to pretend phones never cause problems. Missed inspections, idle machines, and distracted work deserve attention.

So does a shop culture that makes experienced people spend their day finding ways to appear productive.

Todd says the machine is running, the area is clean, and the next job is ready.

After 30 years, wanting a little trust seems pretty damn reasonable.

How does your shop handle cycle time—and does sitting down somehow make the spindle turn slower?

⚡ Sponsored by Built By Machinists

You’ve earned the hoodie. Still waiting on the stool.

The Built By Machinists Logo Hoodie keeps it simple: a micrometer logo on the chest and a nod to the trade that pays the bills. Available in black or carbon grey. $55 USD. Size up—it runs small.