Built By Machinists

You go through shirts fast in the shop. Built By Machinists’ new ±0.0001 Pocket-Tee Bundle gets you three heavyweight, 100% cotton tees for $25 each.

Black to hide the shop grime. A chest pocket for your marker and scale. Standard and Tall sizing.

Shop the 3-pack → https://builtbymachinists.com/products/0-0001-tee-bundle-3-pack

USA only. Limited quantities available.

Good morning, machinists. ☕

Oscar Martinez asked the MACHINIST group a pretty straightforward question:

628 comments later, we had paychecks being compared, pensions being defended, and a few people who probably needed to step away from the keyboard.

But buried in all of that was a detail worth paying attention to.

Oscar wasn’t trying to start a fight. He was finishing tech school, had a family to support, and wanted some guidance before entering the trade.

As he explained later:

So let’s get past the shouting. Here’s what the group had to say.

For the pro-union crowd, the strongest argument was the package: wages, insurance, retirement, time off, and overtime rules.

Mike Hooper put his dues in perspective:

His conclusion?

Scooter Duhaime shared a similar calculation. He said he pays $92 a month in dues, with medical, vision, and dental coverage provided at no cost to him or his family, plus a company-paid pension.

Adam Szcz said joining a union shop meant a $12-an-hour increase for the same work—and he hadn’t reached top rate yet.

Those are individual experiences, of course. They aren’t offers sitting in Oscar’s inbox.

But they explain why “you have to pay dues” wasn’t much of a deterrent for some members.

If the package works, the package works.

The biggest objection wasn’t really the dues.

It was the idea of working harder, knowing more, and getting the same raise as someone who does neither.

Daniel Conway explained his frustration:

That theme came up repeatedly. Members wanted their skills and output to count when it was time for raises, promotions, or layoffs.

Others had a different view: their coworker’s paycheck wasn’t the one they were taking home.

Luke Riddle said his benefits and pay were good, and he wasn’t interested in running himself into the ground worrying about what everyone else was doing.

Same shop-floor frustration. Very different ways of looking at it.

Then Matt Heimbach challenged the idea that protecting poor performers was exclusively a union problem:

A few readers probably pictured someone immediately.

Daniel also described his own non-union benefits: four weeks of PTO to start, an 8% match, an employee stock purchase plan, bonuses, and 13 paid holidays.

He later mentioned flexible start times, too.

Cody Pearson reported a non-union job with $115,000 in annual pay, benefits, a paid phone and truck, and some control over his schedule.

His point was that his employer treated people well—but that wasn’t necessarily typical of every shop around him.

Anthony Jay had perhaps the simplest approach:

That’s a useful distinction.

Oscar is looking for a job he can build a life around. The actual offer matters a whole lot more than winning an argument in the comments.

For someone coming out of tech school, this part deserves more attention.

Several members worried about getting stuck on one machine or one operation. Others credited union apprenticeships and experienced coworkers with teaching them the trade.

Joseph Kolar, who said he had worked both union and non-union over 45 years, praised the union shops where experienced machinists were willing to pass along their knowledge.

Brad Jacob pushed back on the suggestion that union work automatically meant doing the same thing forever:

Meanwhile, John Jacob said he preferred wearing multiple hats in his non-union shop—primarily milling, but jumping on a lathe when needed.

For a new machinist, those are good things to ask about during an interview:

A strong starting wage is great. So is becoming the person who can walk into a shop and make himself useful.

Ideally, you get both.

Some of the strongest opinions came from members who had worked both sides.

Travis Thompson said that after 25 years working non-union, his last five years in a union had made his life “astronomically better.” He also said he had personally seen poor performers let go.

Chuck Faith had the opposite experience. After working in two unions, he said his non-union job of 37 years was the best he’d ever had.

Harrison Stocker offered a fair way to look at the disagreement:

Raphael Morales made another useful point: he had worked both and didn’t have a preference for either, but wanted to avoid workplaces with constant conflict between labor and management.

Fair enough. Most people would rather make parts, get paid, and go home.

One of the best moments came when members were debating six-figure earnings.

Oscar jumped in to explain that $110,000 sounded amazing to someone fresh out of tech school with a family. He wanted to get them back on a decent financial path.

And while everyone else kept arguing, he kept asking people where they worked and whether they were hiring.

Hard to fault that approach.

Dave Lawson summed up the thread nicely:

Oscar may not have gotten a unanimous answer. But he did get some useful questions to take into his job search.

What’s the full compensation package? How do raises work? Who gets laid off first? What will he learn? And what do the people already working there say about the place?

For someone starting out, those answers are worth more than another hundred comments saying “yes” or “hell no.”

Have you worked both union and non-union? What was the biggest difference you actually noticed?

Pay? Benefits? Training? Shop culture?

Hit reply. Preferably before calling anyone a communist.

Camtool, Inc. — Muncie, Indiana

Set up, program, and run a Nomura Swiss lathe at a shop building its own in-house Swiss department. PartMaker preferred.

Looking for an experienced Swiss machinist (5+ years, any brand is fine) who can program and work independently. Monday–Thursday, 4x10, paid weekly. Training on the Nomura is available.

View the job & apply → https://hirecnc.com/job/swiss-programmer-machinist-45823