A meme in the MACHINIST group summed up one hell of a hiring conversation.

The guy in the hard hat says eight guys are retiring for every one who picks up the trade. The guy in the suit asks if he can get hired and learn.

“Absolutely not.”

That’s the whole meme. It reached 58.6K people, got 907 reactions, and kicked off 230 comments in the MACHINIST group.

Patrick Michael Venter had a different read on the picture. Both guys are 25. The guy on the left just has 30–35 years of shop experience.

Which, judging by the comments, makes him the only one qualified to apply.

Entry level. Some time travel required.

Aydon Benson got right to it.

❝

“They all want 15 years of experience but refuse to be the one to give you that experience”

Dustin Bissell had a slightly different version.

❝

“They all want 20 years of experience but only want to pay you for 1 year of experience.”

And Bj Schoonmaker went ahead and wrote the whole damn job ad. You’re 20 years old with 25 years of experience. You can program, set up, and run a job from print to part. Starting pay is $13.50 an hour. One week of vacation kicks in after ten years.

Then came the fine print.

❝

“You must supply your own tools, cutting tools, machines, and bathroom.”

At that point, ask the applicant to bring a customer list too.

The dies paid better on the way out

A few machinists in the thread said they make six figures. Others said the best raise they ever got came when they left the trade.

John Den Bosch had one of the stranger examples. He apprenticed as a toolmaker, got laid off, and went back to trucking. He ended up hauling scrap metal.

❝

“I was shocked to find that hauling scrap die sets to be dismantled paid better than building and maintaining the damned things.”

Imagine spending years learning how to build a die, then finding out the better-paying part of the job is driving it to the scrapyard.

Then there’s Dennis Maddox. He’s 71, still goes in every day to his company’s R&D shop, and says he makes over $100K working alone on a manual lathe and mill. He’s getting ready for retirement by setting up a toolroom lathe and mill at home.

Some guys retire from the shop. Dennis is just cutting the commute.

“No was all we heard.”

Ralph Bougher and his daytime counterpart spent the last few years of their careers asking management to hire someone they could train before they retired.

❝

“No was all we heard.”

Bill Fain had the opposite problem. He was already teaching the operators.

❝

“Was reprimanded once by the shop owner for teaching the operators too much.”

Imagine getting called into the office because the guy next to you understands his job better than he did yesterday.

Other commenters had worked with veterans who kept what they knew close. One said his shop lost a pile of know-how when its master machinist had a stroke. Nobody else had been taught what he knew.

If the only guy who knows how to set up a repeat job is out, how much of that setup can the next guy actually reconstruct from the notes? Anyone who’s opened a folder expecting a setup sheet and found one blurry photo knows how that morning is going to go.

“What if we train them and they leave?”

One commenter said poaching was how he got where he was. From the shop’s side, why spend months training somebody if they’re going to leave as soon as they get good?

Jason Lantsberry answered from the other side of the machine.

❝

“I have no issue staying some where but don’t let the last guy pay me more for the same work or I’m gone”

That’s a pretty recognizable conversation. The shop needs somebody who can get a job running on Monday. The person who’s been learning setups wants to know when that shows up in their paycheck. And the veteran who could teach the next person already has three jobs waiting on him.

One commenter landed in a shop that gave him a shot. He came in with almost zero setup or programming knowledge. A little over two years later, he was programming and setting up his own jobs. He credited the sheer variety of work in a job shop.

I’d love to hear more of those stories. Especially what happened between “watch me do this one” and “you’re setting up the next one.”

Who gave you your first real shot in machining? And what was the first thing they trusted you to do on your own?

📋 Now hiring: Mazak Lathe Machinist | $100K–$120K/yr

International Tool & Manufacturing — Fairfield, New Jersey

Run the lathe side at a small job shop built around tight-tolerance prototype and short-run work, much of it for long-term defense programs. Mazak single-turret horizontal lathes, with programming and editing right at the machine in Mazatrol.

Looking for a senior lathe machinist with 10+ years who can own a job from setup through first article and final inspection. Day shift, overtime as needed. Full medical with no employee contribution, profit sharing, PTO, and paid holidays. Must be eligible to work in the U.S.